Health Canada states: "Stevia
rebaudiana Bertoni is an herbal plant native to South America that
is naturally sweet and which yields a sweet aqueous extract that has
been used for centuries by Guarani natives of Paraguay as a traditional
sweetening substance, added to herbal teas and other beverages. It
is cultivated today in Mexico, Paraguay, Central America, Japan, China,
Malaysia, South Korea and Canada. The dried leaves are 30 to 45 times
as sweet as sucrose. Stevia in the natural herb form including ground
or powdered, in the absence of therapeutic or medicinal claims, is
acceptable as food for the preparation of herbal tea or beverage. Foods
to which stevia in the natural herb form is added as an ingredient,
are classified as novel foods . Classification of stevia extracts depends
on the nature of the preparation. Impure stevia extracts are actually
complex mixtures containing a variety of sweet compounds, including
stevioside. Crude stevia extract is considered a novel food, subject
to notification requirements. Purified stevia extracts in liquid or
crystalline form, in the absence of therapeutic or medicinal claims,
and provided they are not represented for use as sweeteners in other
foods can be sold in Canada as food supplements; ."
Health Canada further states: "Stevioside is a
high intensity sweetener extracted from stevia leaves and isolated
and purified. Stevioside is 250 to 300 times as sweet as sucrose.
When stevioside is extracted from the plant and used to sweeten other
foods that are to be offered for sale, the isolated chemical is considered
to be a food additive. Provision has not been established for the
addition of stevioside to foods in Canada; stevioside is considered
to be a non-permitted sweetener; addition of stevioside to foods
in Canada violates Food and Drug Regulations. Further, any safety
testing of the product 'stevioside' would require consistent characterization
of the tested product. ( Any time a product is the result of extraction
of a natural plant, the risk for co-extraction of contaminants, variability
of plant species, weed infestation, etc. can result in a poorly characterized
product, i.e. not conforming to acceptable specifications, and therefore
producing irreproducible toxicity studies ).
When
asked: "What
about the use as ingredients of stevia and stevia extracts containing
steviosides in other foods offered for sale in Canada?" Health
Canada responded: "This would depend on
the nature of the stevia preparation. If it is actually stevia in
leaf, cut up or powdered from or a crude stevia extract ( i.e. as opposed
to a purified extract ) then the food in which stevia is used might
be considered a Novel Food. The EU ( already ) considers stevia
itself to be a Novel Food. It has already been indicated that
the Health Protection Branch had no regulations in place a number of
years ago when a request to sell the leaves as such was made. The Novel
Foods Regulations are new and were promulgated at the end of 1999.
These regulations require notification for Novel Foods having no history
of safe use and these regulations safety data could be requested. The
department cannot control how the consumer used leaves or stevia extracts
in the home, but the department can control or at least have the
opportunity to evaluate safety data in advance in the case of stevia
or stevia extracts ( steviosides ) being used as a sweetening ingredient
in other foods which are offered for sale. As stated previously, while
stevia extracts may be sold in themselves as food supplements, their
representation for use as table-top sweeteners or as high intensity
sweeteners in other food render them food additives are subject to
pre-clearance." |